MSCI confirms Strategy will be dropped from its indexes on Nov. 30
MSCI's November review removes Strategy, the largest corporate bitcoin holder, at the Nov. 30 close, forcing index-tracking funds to sell, outlets reported.
MSCI has decided to delete Strategy (MSTR), the largest corporate holder of bitcoin, from its indexes, with the change taking effect at the close of Nov. 30. BWEnews, citing a filing and Reuters, reported the removal shortly after 5 p.m. New York time on Wednesday, and Watcher.Guru carried the same news.
Outlets differ on which index is affected. BeInCrypto said Strategy leaves the MSCI USA Index, while the Reuters line relayed by BWEnews referred to the MSCI Global Standard Indexes. No outlet reported a statement from Strategy on the decision.
Why MSCI cut the company
On Oct. 15, MSCI finalized a rule that makes "non-operating companies" ineligible for its Global Investable Market Indexes. Bitcoin Magazine reported that the rule does not mention bitcoin. It first checks whether operating assets exceed 50% of total assets, then applies five financial ratios, and a company that fails four or more is ineligible.
A current constituent is removed only if it fails in each of its two most recent annual filing periods. Bitcoin Magazine noted that Strategy adopted fair-value accounting for its bitcoin at the start of 2025, and that MSCI had not said how it treats the earlier year. Strategy has argued that its bitcoin treasury is an operating segment. In an August letter, it said a deletion would have no meaningful impact on its business, according to Bitcoin Magazine.
MSCI's October draft list had already marked five companies as deleted: Strategy, Yellow Cake, Metaplanet, Skel Fjárfestingafélag and Upexi. Bitcoin Magazine said Strategy made up more than 90% of that group by float-adjusted market value. No outlet has yet reported Metaplanet's final status.
What forced selling could look like
Funds that track an MSCI index must hold what the index holds, so they will have to sell Strategy shares by the Nov. 30 close. JPMorgan analysts estimated that an MSCI exclusion could prompt about $2.8 billion of selling, and up to $8.8 billion more if other index providers followed. Bitcoin.com News, Bitcoin Magazine and BeInCrypto all noted that the estimate was built on MSCI's earlier proposal rather than the final rules, and Bitcoin Magazine said MSCI has published no figure of its own.
Strategy disclosed in August that funds tracking MSCI indexes held about 13 million of its shares, or 3.1% of basic shares outstanding, according to Bitcoin.com News. Bitcoin Magazine said removal would not delist the stock and that nothing in the rules forces the company to sell bitcoin. The pressure would fall on the shares and on the premium Strategy relies on when it sells stock to fund purchases.
The stock had already weakened. Bitcoin.com News reported MSTR closed at $121.07 on Nov. 10, down from $145.16 on Oct. 28, with bitcoin near $73,700 at the time. BeInCrypto reported a Wednesday close of $122.35, then a 0.85% slide to $121.31 in after-hours trading as the list appeared. Trader Kaleo, quoted by Bitcoin.com News, said the outcome was likely priced in and would have little fundamental effect on bitcoin.
What remains open
The main date is Nov. 30, when tracking funds must trade. Whether other index providers follow MSCI, the scenario behind JPMorgan's larger $8.8 billion estimate, is unresolved.
Strategy added 1,036 BTC last week, bringing its holdings to 850,364 BTC, according to Bitcoin.com News. That buying was funded by selling MSTR stock, which is the funding route a loss of passive demand would affect. Michael Saylor, in comments BeInCrypto cited, said MSCI should mirror the market rather than arbitrate it.
Sources
- MSCI Rules on Strategy Today and Billions in Forced Selling Hang on It Bitcoin.com News
- MSCI Rules Today on Cutting Strategy (MSTR) From Its Indexes After a Draft List Marks It Deleted Bitcoin Magazine
- MicroStrategy Officially Removed from MSCI Indexes Starting End of Month: Filing BWEnews
- MSCI: Strategy Inc to Be Deleted Form MSCI Global Standard Indexes - Reuters BWEnews
- MSCI to officially remove Michael Saylor's Strategy MSTR from its indexes by the end of this month Watcher.Guru
- MSCI Drops Strategy From Its US Index: Will $2.8 Billion in Forced Selling Hit MSTR? BeInCrypto
Written with AI assistance from the sources above and checked against them. Not investment advice.